OPEN SPACE
 

Return to Grape home page  Return to list of Open Space topics
 

Rumours of defaulting bidders at the CWG auction 16 January 2007

From Ori Berkowitz:
Apologies for the tangent. On the subject of the CWG auction – there were rumours that a vast quantity of wine was purchased by a bidder present on the day at the event, who, after receiving his invoice, claimed the bidding process was ambiguous and promptly refused to purchase what he had successfully bid for. Has anyone heard anything on this matter perhaps? Surely there are checks in place for this kind of thing? Someone after the event suggested that translators be available for foreign folks and for the JB Coetzees of this world. I had a Belgian dame next to me who was asking for explanations throughout the morning.

Anyone know of this botch up and wines subsequently unsold, forfeited or written off? Worth calling the Guild to snap up a bargain perhaps? For charity of course...
 

Response: We asked the CWG for their comment on this, and new Chair Philip Costandius replied as follows (with no cheerful news for those looking for a bargain, I fear, Ori):

 

The Nedbank Cape Winemakers Guild annual Auction represents a particular type of contract between the buyers and sellers of exclusive wines.  The bidding procedure is structured in the same way as many other wine Auctions throughout the world and this method has proven over the years to be successful and acceptable to most bidders.

The Conditions of Sale are clearly printed in the Auction Catalogue and on the reverse of the Auction Registration Card that every Auction buyer has to sign.  These Conditions are read out by the Auctioneer at the beginning of the Auction and repeated at various stages throughout the day. There is and was nothing 'ambiguous about the bidding process'.

It is in the interests of the Guild that both the Guild member and the buyer get the best deal out of the Auction. For the member, it is selling all the lots at the best possible price and for the buyer; it is getting 'value for money'.  There is also no ambiguity in this; our intentions are very clear and explicit.

As with any other commercial venture, the Guild has, in the past, fallen prey to buyers who default or pay late.  Fortunately we have managed to keep such losses to a minimum and we have always exercised a measure of grace with late payers.  Legal action is a last resort.

Any wine left unsold due to buyer default can be offered to other buyers at the average price obtained at the Auction.  This is done during or immediately after the Auction, should such circumstances arise. Defaulted wine represented only a small percentage of the 2006 Auction turnover and was very happily snapped up by other auction buyers.

 

CLICK HERE TO SEND US YOUR COMMENT