South Africa's independent wine viewpoint

 
 

Click here to receive regular email updates of what's new on Grape

   
Home
News
Views & tastes
Recent releases
From the coalface
Fridjhon weekly
Cathy's blog
The Widow
Open space
More about Grape
Magazine archive
Links: SA wine
Contacting us

 

 

The Widow's sour grapes

Back to Widow's contents pages

Follye and weeknesse 14 March 2006

Glancing, as is my occasional wont, through the Collected Works of Dean Swift, I came across the following in his Resolutions for When I Come to be Old: ‘Not to be over severe with young People, but give Allowances for their youthfull follyes, and weeknesses.’ Being already a candidate for the follyes of antientnesse, I am minded to remember some other advice (this time from the English journalist Katharine Whitehorn): that is, never to say ‘I’m just a silly old woman’. Some of you young people might be fool enough to believe me.

 

Product placement possibilities
Cannibalism must count as a notable weeknesse, even a follye, in young or old. I see that there is to be a film about that German cannibal who made the headlines and Sunday back pages a year or two back. Will the film be high-mindedly honest, or will they be open to offers, I wonder – product placement being a big thing these days. You’ll remember, I’m sure, that the famous meal of freshly sliced, er, sausage-thingy was apparently accompanied by an unspecified ‘South African Cabernet Sauvignon’. So I’m sure Wosa and all of us will be eagerly awaiting the revelation of just which one it was. But would the producer of the genuine article sue if it was shown? Or if it wasn’t?

 

Oscar the braaimeister
Talking of strange meals, the Nederburg Auction is coming up (though the wines that accompany the luncheon tends to be less strange than tedious, often including Nederburg stuff that hasn’t managed to sell at Auction for a few years). The lunch usually provides a welcome break for the uncomfortably overdressed visitors wondering why on earth they bothered to turn out again on a hot summer Saturday in Paarl. But often the food is a matter more of pomp and ceremony than of haute cuisine.

The organisers always keep the menu as a surprise – it helps to lessen the blow, I think. And word is that this year it will be an even bigger surprise than last year’s somewhat chaotic effort (when many of the Cape’s finest chefs prepared what optimists called ‘adventurous wine-matching dishes’, served in random and much-delayed order). I am told (and you know how reliable my informants always are) that the sit-down do is to be abandoned. Instead, the ladies in hats will be offered a casual, stand-around braai (one can already hear grumblings about suburban down-market affairs).

And guess who’s cooking the boerewors on the coals (served in pieces on a stick with a piece of potato to dip into blatjang)? Why, our favourite über-operator Oscar Foulkes! Oscar, sporting a frenzy of bleached curls these days, is to lend a hand to wife Andrea, who seems to have clinched the lucrative contract to give auction lunchers some zooped-up boerekos.


Taint in wine and words

And the wines. I shall be intrigued to see if De Toren Fusion V 2000 actually makes it to the Auction podium. At the media tasting all three sample bottles were pretty badly tainted – corked, I’m told, or some such horrible fate. No further bottles were available, so if the tasting hacks present were in the habit of responsible reporting (don’t laugh!), they would surely have been justified in informing the world of high-paying potential buyers world that there there was either incredible bad luck involved, or at least a batch of Fusion V to be treated in very gingerly fashion. A bad situation for one of the Cape’s most hyped and expensive wines.

Interestingly there’s also a bit of serious taint in the official auction catalogue comment on the Fusion V 2000. It claims that the wine ‘was never released in South Africa’ and that it ‘was rated five stars in both the John Platter South African Wine Guide and Wine magazine’. Well, I don’t have old copies of the mag, but my copy of Platter 2003 edition shows the wine getting only four-and-half stars (the guide has never given the wine five stars). There’s also the statement in Platter (presumably info given by the producer) that all of the wine in question was ‘sold out in 5 months’. Sounds like misinformation both then and now. How did the Auction catalogue get so much wrong? Is the rest of it to be trusted?

Meanwhile, it seems like that high tower might be catching plenty of uncomfortable winds.

 

Cork-screwed
Cork taint was not an unusual occurrence at this Auction media tasting. Despite being pre-tasted (by whom, one wonders), some bottles had to be replaced for the wine-writing crowd; never the most outspoken and critical of creatures these, but there was a general swoosh of enthusiasm for screwcaps. Not that many local producers are taking the move to better protection seriously. Apparently the recently established International Screwcap Initiative is getting very few enquiries from the Cape. Other than from Constantia Uitsig, Rustenburg and Hidden Valley, I believe, the silence is deafening. Maybe if the hacks were to tell potential Auction buyers about the tainted wines they found, producers might get the wake-up call.

 

Stop press
I see with sadness that advocate Mr John van den Berg (former owner of Cloof) has just been struck off the rolls. Just because he threated to sue me once for innocently mentioning his nickname (‘Vark’ – but he denied it vehemently), doesn’t mean I won’t remember him most fondly for turning up at a Wine magazine luncheon (his Pinotage had won something) and embarrassing everyone by bringing as his special guest Jürgen Harksen, the German fraudster now languishing in clink. (Come to think of it, Harksen is another German baddie they’re planning to make a film about. Again I wonder if Cloof will object to being included.... Maybe Oscar will get the catering contract while they’re filming on the property, seeing he’s there already.)

 

COMMENT

From Tasting Hack:
Dear Widow – You're being too harsh on the hacks. Pendock in the Financial Mail 24/2/2006:

Reds were generally less impressive, with the incidence of cork taint a worrying phenomenon. With two bottles of De Toren Fusion V 2000 musty, you'll have to be feeling as lucky as Clint Eastwood to make a bid. Emil den Dulk must be furious as the tainted wine would have been a show stopper if hadn't had a cork stopper.

Widow's reply: Oh. Sorry, Neil. (Sometimes when I get things wrong I can blame my informants, sometimes it's my own sheer incompetence or ignorance).

 

CLICK HERE TO SEND US YOUR COMMENT