South Africa's independent wine viewpoint

 
 
   
Home
News
Views & tastes
Recent releases
Foreign fling
From the coalface
Fridjhon weekly
Cathy's blog
The Widow
Open space
More about Grape
Magazine archive
Links: SA wine
Contacting us

 

 

The Widow's sour grapes

Back to Widow's contents pages

Pinotage for Valentine, and other
thoughts and emotions

5 February 2008

 

Here’s a ghastly thought, and I can almost hear Andre van Rensburg saying – well, they have to find something to do with the bloody stuff, seeing it’s undrinkable…. Mont Destin, you see, is offering a Valentine’s Day bath ‘for you and your partner’  in the middle of a vineyard – in ‘a heady mix of Pinotage and warm water’. It seems you’re not expected to drink the bathwater if you have a yen for the stuff, as they also offer a bottle of ‘double gold award winning Pinotage’ along with the towels, etc. (Surprising, perhaps, that Beyers Truter hadn’t thought about this idea – perhaps it sounds a bit immoral for him – but seeing he already makes just about everything from pinotage, from jam to port, perhaps they could persuade him to produce some pinotage soap and shampoo?)

Dear Cathy van Zyl once shudderingly said that she wouldn’t even drink Amarula Cream if it was poured all over Brad Pitt. I wonder if she’d bath with him in pinotage? I myself would rather like a bath all by myself in Madeira – something like an old vintage Bual, perhaps. I might never get out. But if you’re weird and have R1500 to spare, get in touch with Mont Destin.

If, however, you have about 30 times that amount to treat your beloved with and you’re in London, and you want to support some South Africans abroad, you could have the special menu at the Vivat Bacchus restaurant owned by Neleen Strauss and Gerrie Knoetze. R14000 was the price I saw quoted, presumably per person. Caviar, lobster, fancy ham from Spain and beef from Australia, cheese and chocolate from Europe, are on offer. Along with some very fancy wines – patriotically they’ve included a chenin from the Cape (from Ken Forrester, who seems to manage to get in just about everywhere that promises a bit of publicity) but I didn’t notice pinotage. Perhaps that’s flowing in the hand-basins.

 

Hopeful...

Talking of the Scourge of Pinotage, I see we’ve reported elsewhere on Vergelegen’s triumphs at Jancis’s wine tastings for for the rich, famous, powerful and expense-accounted at the World Economic Forum. She noted in her report the presence of the chief of Anglo American, Cynthia Caroll, who assured her how dear Vergelegen was to her heart. I do hope that this has been noted by the perniciously persistent perpetrator of the prediction that she’s determined to sell the place. But who cares about evidence for strange ideas?

 

Wrong...

When I’m wrong, I’m wrong and must admit it. And I was wrong about Deetlefs Estate when I didn’t apply my normal principle of believing the best about people. With reports of them not wanting to be mentioned in Platter this year because the wines aren’t tasted blind, I’d put them down as whingers being egged on in their whingeing by others advancing their own questionable interests. I imagined that Deetlefs must think they deserved better, and felt they would get it by blind tasting.

So I turned to the online records of Wine mag, to see how they performed in the country’s most prominent set of blind tasting line-ups. Well! If my arithmetic is right, out of 45 Deetlefs wines rated in recent years, only 8 had rated three stars or above – about the same number that had rated rock-bottom one star. Surely this must be one of the worst blind-tasting track records of any producer?

So I have come to the conclusion that Deetlefs is embarrassed at doing so well in Platter – in the 2007 edition they get four four-star ratings, and nothing less than two stars. They appararently ache for the simple justice of the low scores they get in blind tastings. In all fairness, then, I shall disregard, for example, the four stars they got for their Semillon in Platter, because it was achieved by Platter’s horribly unfair system; Wine mag’s blind-tasting system gave the Deetlefs wine two stars (and in a separate tasting gave it two-and-a half, which is unusual consistency for Wine), so that must be what Deetlefs thinks the wine is worth. So be it, and let hem be praised for their honesty, if not for their wine.

(Note, it must be said that various people connected with Grape are involved in the production of Platter - though not me of course - but this is less a declaration of interest than an apology for suggesting that perhaps they've overrated Deetlefs wines in the past.)

 

Sad...

I know that I have many admirers, secret and otherwise, but few were as open in their affection for me as was the late Raoul Beaumont of Beaumont Wines. Even apart from that, as an integral part of one of the nicest families in Cape wine, he will be much missed.

COMMENT

From TT:
Nice timing, Wid. I see that Wine.co.za is carrying what they laughably call a 'news' item from Deetlefs, repeating their whinge. Does anyone know how much you have to pay Wine.co.za for this sort of service to independent journalism?
 

From Anonymous:
Perhaps Deetlefs could publish a list of all their awards, so we can see just how biased those wicked sighted tasters have been towards their expensive Anthony Lane-designed labels. What of other ‘superior’ blind tasting judgements of their Familie range of (4 white, 1 red) wines, each costing an aspirational R300 (yes, really) a bottle. One wonders how much of the small 250-case production of the Familie Semillon 2005 (still available in 2008 since release in 2006) they’ve managed to sell at this price. Readers can judge Deetlefs wines for themselves - if they’re prepared to travel, or otherwise part with a couple of thousand for the privilege.

 

 

CLICK HERE TO SEND US YOUR COMMENT